Proper Pasty Company Ltd - Sheffield

Sarah T.

Do not buy the all day breakfast pasty. It has a tiny plastic looking sausage, and loads of baked beans. The pastry was absolutely vile and disgusting. If your expecting anything else in this all day breakfast, don't bother. They take your money and skimp on the ingredients. They have sent us a wrong pasty that we didn't want. We've explained that the markings on the all day breakfast is similar to the steak and Stilton. I commented that it be good to wrap individual pasties and write on them what they are instead of a near enough a4 poster showing the markings. Plus explained that with them being different flavours, wouldn't they tarnish their flavours onto others.
The one they sent smells like curry and we didn't order that. After the email I sent, all they could say was they would inform their staff. No apologies, no refund, no offering of a free lot of pasties.

Avoid this company with your life's. Save your money and go somewhere else.

Jack S.

The van used to come to us every day with us giving 5+ customers £40+, the company has decided to not come here due to other business giving more revenue, this company obviously doesn’t care about its customers and only cares about the extra penny. “Business is business” - from the customer service person.

Richard L.

Really looking forward to eating these pastys but they had very little meat. The pastry was extremely tough over worked. Nearly resorted to steak knives to get through it. Unfortunately I will not be ordering again.

Aaron L.

After been told we don’t spend enough - it was decided they no longer want us to serve us even though £40 a day isn’t sufficient enough, after ringing to ask why a response of “business is business” to which they didn’t care in the slightest! Awful customer service and rude would be an understatement.

George S.

After many orders my last one of eight giant pasties was a great disappointment as too salty.,peppery and very little meat. Response from company poor as they are sorry but we have wasted £35 because we couldn’t eat them

Ben R.

Second time of ordering 10x pick your own and 24 cheese and onion rolls second time of not being disappointed 10/10 from moi! Merry Christmas proper pasty family! Had to destroy the pasty though for better pic 😭

corriene T.

Received my order 8 x Steak and Gravy Pasties , 4 x Sausage Rolls , quick delivery however the pasties had to much pasty it was think around the edges it went hard during the cooking from frozen process as advised, some way inconsistent in size some big small not fillings / steak in them , Sausage rolls lacked flavour and sausage meat tasted cheap. Only tired one of each had high hopes on these but left a little underwhelmed . Won’t buy or recommend for £36:99 better out there !

Laura F.

Absolutely DO NOT BUY! I ordered the ten pick and mix pasties. 4 cheese and bacon, 3 steak and Stilton, 3 cheese and onion. CHEESE AND BACON - no cheese in this pasty at all. Instead you get watery potato pieces and bacon. Shocking! Demanded a refund on these as and was told you won’t see cheese but it is a cheese sauce. I assure you it is not a cheese sauce. No taste of cheese at all. I am getting a refund for these. STEAK AND STILTON - no sign of Stilton anywhere, again watery potato pieces and shreds of steak. Shocking! CHEESE AND ONION - again no sign of any cheese and no sign of onion. Instead a weird sauce and again lots of potato pieces. These pasties are bulked out with so much little pieces of potato, the pastry is thick and not good at all. Cheese does not exist in these pasties at all. Absolute waste of money. How this company can make and sell these awful tasteless pasties is shocking! They need to state clearly they do not use actual cheese and that they contain 80% potato. DO NOT ORDER. I DO NOT RECOMMEND.